Summer 2016: The Forum, Los Angeles, CA (photo by David Tosti)
....<....>.............<........ posting below .´
¡¡¡¡¡ >.,"": *& £££ £££ £££ ££

Monday, January 25, 2010

Obama DOJ Defends $675,000 File-sharing Damages Award

Authored by Mark Hefflinger on January 20, 2010 - 11:28am.
Washington - The Obama Justice Dept. has submitted a filing defending a $675,000 damages award for copyright infringement on a file-sharing network, the Copyrights and Campaigns blog reported. Joel Tenenbaum was found guilty of sharing 30 songs on Kazaa, and ordered to pay the record labels damages of $22,500 per song. He has since asked the court to either reduce the damages or grant him a new trial, arguing the damages amount is unconstitutional.

In its filing, the Justice Dept. argues that Tenenbaum's actions caused "great public harm."

"In establishing the range [of copyright damage amounts: $750 to $150,000 per infringement], Congress took into account the need to deter the millions of users of new media from infringing copyrights in an environment where many violators believe they will go unnoticed," reads the DOJ filing.

"The harms Congress sought to address, moreover, are not negated merely because an infringer does not seek commercial gain. Accordingly, the statutory range specified by Congress for a copyright infringement satisfies due process."
I hope this ruling deters others from continuing to use illegal means of downloading music. Wow, $22,500 per song. That would definitely help me support my wife and son!


James said...


I understand the ethical, legal, and (in your case) personal reasons to oppose illegally downloading music. However, I think supporting an arguably unjust ruling that could ruin someone's life (or at least severely damage it for a long period) isn't the correct moral path either.

cass said...

agreed.... while it is wrong to steal a song, I hardly think it is worth destroying someone's life over... maybe this guy has a wife and kid to support too... to put him in debt and his family in debt for generations is hardly a good way to deal with something...

Melanie said...

Yea, too bad you probably would never see any of it. Here is my main problem: the damages aren't any where close to reality and if the damages are that punitive, they should be the result of a criminal not civil ruling, imho.

Vintage cab used on MM debut (two 15" Jensen speakers).